Need advice on grahic card or something else
BunFest
30 May 2009 13:56
I bought a 24 inches monitor. It is very impressive to watch my HD footage on a real HD monitor 1920X1080. However I still have problem to watch my HD clips ( MOV h.264 and mpeg 2 ) smoothly, not choppy. So I bought a new Grahic card : Sapphine Radeon HD4670 Ultimate. The problem is not solve, only faster rendering. ( At least a improvement! ) . My CPU is Intel Core 2 Duo E6300.
Strange is I play my clip MOV format on QuickTime Player, still choppy..
CPU is Intel Core 2 Duo E6300
Sapphine Radeon HD4670 Ultimate
Ram 4 Gb
Anyone has an idea of how to improve or what is missing in my system.
Thanks for your suggestions in advance.
Pat
Strange is I play my clip MOV format on QuickTime Player, still choppy..
CPU is Intel Core 2 Duo E6300
Sapphine Radeon HD4670 Ultimate
Ram 4 Gb
Anyone has an idea of how to improve or what is missing in my system.
Thanks for your suggestions in advance.
Pat
zygistudio
30 May 2009 15:56
Problem could be fragmented or slow speed hard drive. Try to defragment first and check if it helps. Or use a separate HD for clips you previewing.
Edited:
I use the Performance Test program to check my hardware: http://www.passmark.com/products/pt.htm
Edited:
I use the Performance Test program to check my hardware: http://www.passmark.com/products/pt.htm
BunFest
30 May 2009 16:09
I had a totally new HD and I found out the QT player play on 20fps instead of 30fps. (Thanks for Jake´s answer on other subject.) And it seems QT player did not use GPU power? Is it truth ? Is it a problem of weak CPU or weak GPU ?
I watch internet video from Apple site, the video are beautifully smooth with my old notebook. Why not on my PC with :
CPU is Intel Core 2 Duo E6300
Sapphine Radeon HD4670 Ultimate
Ram 4 Gb.
Pat
I watch internet video from Apple site, the video are beautifully smooth with my old notebook. Why not on my PC with :
CPU is Intel Core 2 Duo E6300
Sapphine Radeon HD4670 Ultimate
Ram 4 Gb.
Pat
dnavarrojr
30 May 2009 16:20
Pat,
I have a quad core 3.2 GHz processor with 16 GB of RAM and a very fast 750 GB main drive in my computer and I still get choppiness playing full screen MOV files in Windows. I think it's QuickTime and not your computer. I don't think it does enough caching before it starts to play. When I play them in VLC the choppiness goes away.
I have a quad core 3.2 GHz processor with 16 GB of RAM and a very fast 750 GB main drive in my computer and I still get choppiness playing full screen MOV files in Windows. I think it's QuickTime and not your computer. I don't think it does enough caching before it starts to play. When I play them in VLC the choppiness goes away.
BunFest
30 May 2009 17:06
dnavarrojr,
Thanks for your comment.
It made me feel better after I heard that you higher end PC has the same problem too.
The new graphic card does a faster job when rendering. However is it quick to render a 14 minutes (or 4 GB long) clips into Time-lapse around 30 minutes time.
It seems my consumer software--Magix did a bad job for extreme Time- Lapse, like 14 minutes long moving cloud into 10-15 second. It becomes un-usable noisy and the black-grey-white are in steps. Not a smooth gradation as the cloud should be like.
Is a professional software, AE or CS4 can solve this problem. I guess so, stupid question??
Pat
Thanks for your comment.
It made me feel better after I heard that you higher end PC has the same problem too.
The new graphic card does a faster job when rendering. However is it quick to render a 14 minutes (or 4 GB long) clips into Time-lapse around 30 minutes time.
It seems my consumer software--Magix did a bad job for extreme Time- Lapse, like 14 minutes long moving cloud into 10-15 second. It becomes un-usable noisy and the black-grey-white are in steps. Not a smooth gradation as the cloud should be like.
Is a professional software, AE or CS4 can solve this problem. I guess so, stupid question??
Pat
stefgo
30 May 2009 21:26
HDD speed is rarely the cause for choppy playbacks of HDV or H.264 compressed clips. I guess it´s mostly the processor that isn´t fast enough to undo the compression "on the fly " for smooth playback.
Nevertheless, VLC Player plays almost all my HDV (m2t) files perfectly on a 5 year old P4, 3GB RAM. Much better than QTP or Streamclip and without washed out colors. I use Streamclip only for encoding now.
BTW: A good codec for previewing clips is DVCPRO, quality 100%. It is frame accurate like mjpeg but has DV bitrate, 28 mbps, and pretty decent quality at full HD size. Those files play like charm, and if they do not it´s very likely the clip that has a problem, not your hardware.
Stefan
Nevertheless, VLC Player plays almost all my HDV (m2t) files perfectly on a 5 year old P4, 3GB RAM. Much better than QTP or Streamclip and without washed out colors. I use Streamclip only for encoding now.
BTW: A good codec for previewing clips is DVCPRO, quality 100%. It is frame accurate like mjpeg but has DV bitrate, 28 mbps, and pretty decent quality at full HD size. Those files play like charm, and if they do not it´s very likely the clip that has a problem, not your hardware.
Stefan