Anybody interested in doing a monthly critique group?

If you ask a lawyer, he will answer: "stay away from those waters". We can criticize P5 and equipment but once you judge an individual, it's another legal matter. This is not a bar where you can throw words into the air and they vanish. Here they stay written.

You are free to make your criticism group, but count me out. The best sellers here follow Vader's simple lesson: "Shut-up and shoot."

@RedMoonRisingStudios Sounds good to me, do you want to run it on here, or would it work through FaceBook or WordPress for example? I hear you about the pricing debate, but it would be interesting to discuss how we arrive at that all important decision.

I think it should be a moderated discussion on Facebook of contributors who agree with your proposition. For everyone that responds here, twenty read.

criticize who?

if you want to criticize the staff or p5, you can just
send them an email. they will answer in a couple of days
and it will be clean and to the point.

if you want authors to criticize eachother, i dont exactly
agree with that... it depends on the market you upload to.
but it will dillute originality i think. it would make ppl
upload stuff that resembles each other's work.
i think it might affect the variety / diversity, that should exist...
unless, of course, it's just technical criticism.

I think criticism of others is the domain of musicians! ;)

I have sold several shaky unsharpen clips for a higher price like 100$ where you can critize everything. So, what is wrong when it sells? Who is the master?

"The best sellers here follow Vader's simple lesson: "Shut-up and shoot.""

Good! :D

yes I would I need help I have a noise in all of the pictures with a canon t2i

I like this idea. We could also include critiques for display, SEO, selling tips and sometimes a word of encouragement every now and then.